The didn't smell to strongly or terrible. My pup loved them and they are a fantastic price!

Not sure about taste, but my sweet girl sure did seem to like them. 😂

My dog loveessss these

These are the perfect size dog treats for training a puppy to potty train. Our maltipoo loves them!

Have a dog that doesn't want to listen, get these. Game changer! My dogs love them and will listen to any command.

Motivates our puppy to follow commands. She really likes them!

My dog loved these!

Great training treats for my pup. He likes the flavor. I didn't try them

Loved this. My dog was highly motivated by them and loved the flavor and scent and I loved the value for money. UNTIL they recently raised the price and now I'm disappointed and not sure what training treats to use. They're good but not worth the price raise.

Dogs love it. I have a Pomeranian and Chorkie and am able to split each piece in 2 for training. It's chewey and soft.

I thought these twice now and my dogs love them! My dad's dog is 2-year-old female German Shepherd and she is never had any training period when I come to visit I bring these treats and it's literally the only thing that will get her to sit on command.

Dogs love this stuff I got it for 2:50$ I got three of each flavors pretty good for training and price

My puppy live these!

My dog LOVES these. They're great for training and great considering the price.

I bought this for training shiba inu puppy. I am glad he likes it . It is nice moist chewy treat and easy to cut small. I will buy it again.

Dog does not care

I've ordered multiple packs of these treats (in multiple flavors) for training my dog. I like that they're soft, so when I'm doing a lot of work with her I can break them in half and they don't crumble apart. She really likes them!

I only bought this to make the free shipping requirement but n dog loves rhen!

My dog will eat anything, but she still has favorites. And, she gets super excited for these morsels. She really seems to like the smell and taste. The ingredients are healthy with nothing artificial, so that makes me happy.

My dog loves these treats! I will buy them again!

Perfect for training...small but happily rexceived treats. Fresh and tasty...dogs love 'em. The quantity is reasonable too. Like quality.

The product description was wrong; it said over 180 treats and there were 120. However, they are soft and easy to make into smaller pieces and my Pom puppy LOVES them!

My pup loves these! It's really aided in his training, he gets so excited when I pull out the bag, he'll do anything for one. The smell, while not exactly pleasant, isn't overwhelming. Perfect size for quick rewards without breaking the flow of training. They're soft and chewy so I would recommend brushing after feeding so they don't stay stuck in your pops teeth and cause bad breath.

I have been using these for training my 3.5 month old puppy. He loves them. I have been breaking them in half just so he doens't get too much in training sessions, but they are super easy to break, but not too crumbly. They are sucha good deal!

My dog loved them

Much bigger treat than I was expecting! but they are still great. I split it up into fourths and give them to my puppy.

I give my dogs treats when they go potty outside. I need something very small or my 10 pound dog would get full on treats. These are the size of small cat kibble. They smell very strongly like beef jerky, so even my other dog who is not very food motivated loves these. Ingredients list is simple. Price is awesome!

my pup loves them

Dogs can be picky like mine he will eat them but he doesn't got wild over these as much as other treats. I got these because they are made with Salman which is good for their over all health and with min pin having skin issues I try to get my boy all the Salman that I can.

Great dog treats for a great price! My dog loves them. You can even squish them into bones or puzzle toys for a good dog distraction

My puppy absolutely loves these treats and they are wonderfully priced for the quality. I do notice my dog loves smokey smelling treats and these are no exception. They are even easy to break up into little pieces for training purposes.

These treats smell amazing and my puppies love them. I am also happy ingredients wise for this product.

My puppy love the flavor

My Australian Cattle dog loves these tiny treats. There is a lot in that bag, so it is definitely worth the price that I paid which was only $1.99 for a 4 oz. bag.

Love the small size. Cuts the calories during training

Perfect for training treats and small pups.

Good size and dog loves the taste

My puppy absolutely seemed to like these treats. The product appeared to be fresh and soft.

My dog wasnt sure at first but then she tried them and loved them

Great price dogs love them.

Healthy treat and my dog loves them

I ordered these treats in a few different flavors and this is the favorite hands down. They have a good smell to them that the dogs want to do tricks for lol but At the same time, it's not too strong for my nose either. Reasonable price, you get quite a few of them in the bag. Great value!

I'm surprised to see that some pets didn't like these. Our dog likes them and we love giving them to him. He's a 5 year old Australian Sheppard mix and we use these (both flavors) for training when we are away from home. At home we use homemade treats however they require refrigeration so these are much easier to take along on walks, hikes, etc. I don't find them to have a strong odor and I like that they are small but I can still break them apart easily. We have added these to our subscribe & save orders do we won't run out.

Our dog has to take an allergy pill twice a day. I've been using these soft treats to hide the pill in and they work great! Lenny has no idea that he's taking his medication. He just thinks that he's been a good boy.

Nice treats I've never seen locally. Price keeps going up here. Other than that, wonderful.However, not for picky dogs.

Cheap! Puppy LOVES! :)

My dog loves them. Good price too!

My dog absolutely loves these.

My 7 month old mini goldendoodle loves these treats. All I need to do is shake the bag and she comes running. I saw them on sale with the other flavor she likes and so I bought 3 of each to stalk up since she loves them so much.