We got these in our "puppy pack" when we picked up our new puppy. We realized the other treats we bought for her were chewier than expected, not so great for training. So, we tried these and she absolutely loved them immediately. We use these and plain boiled chicken for her training. These treats are really easy to break up so we can control the size of her treats. They do leave a slight residue on our fingers but that will be the case for any treat you are handling. Plus, the price is amazing for these! Great for if you're on a budget but I'm also genuinely surprised they are not more expensive.My only qualm is that I do wish these were lower calorie. They are 4 calories per treat and I prefer that my training treats are only 1 calorie. However, as I mentioned, these treats are easy to break up into bits and "portion control," so to speak.

Thought they'd be bad considering the few recent reviews but the dogs liked it. It's easy to mold and I could see it be used as a pill pocket.

I can't believe how much my puppy loves Lil' Bitz! :) we got the beef flavored ones. They have a smoky smell which drives my puppy crazy, they're soft and easy to break off! This makes a perfect training treat!

My lab loved these treats. I liked that the scent was not as powerful as some other treats I've bought before. One thing I did notice was that they made my dog really thirsty, so I started cutting back on how often I gave them to her.

I've been looking around for treats that are suited to cats because there just aren't a lot of soft treats on the market for cats (for some reason). Sadly, the cats didn't have great interest in these--one wouldn't even try them. No stars taken off for that because they aren't formulated for cats.My dog thinks they're great though, so off they go to the dog treat stockpile! They're a little big for training treats, but they're very easy to break apart. They feel pretty saturated with oil so don't leave them on top of anything you don't want stained! The ingredient list is short and has nothing worrying in it, which is what I look for in everything my animals eat.

These are tiny little soft treats. My puppy loves them. It works for me because I can split the treat into tinier pieces while training and my puppy is not too full and therefore very much motivated.

On the back its says that it does NOT make your hands smell, well it does! It's very misleading and hate having bacon smelling hands and having to wash my hands after handling treats 5+ times a day to train my puppy!

My dog go insane for these treats, I haven't met a dog who doesn't. They'll do anything you ask because the treats taste good to all dogs including picky eaters. They do smell a little bit strong but that's what gets ALL the dogs attention. They're also all natural!!

These are great treats. Small, soft, easy to use for training, and my dog really likes them. Can't beat the price.

I like these treats and my dog enjoys them, but there are a little too big in my opinion and are a little sticky

My dog gets so excited for these. She will stop whatever she is doing if she hears the bag, sees or smells them. The number 1 training treat. â¤

My puppy loves these treats it's like she wants to do what ever I say to get a treat hahaha but I would definitely purchase again

My dogs really like these treats, the smell of them gets their attention and I really like the size of the treats. Our puppy is being trained for 4H so she gets a lot of treats and these are nice because they are not big enough to fill her up quickly and she is willing to work for them.

My sisters dogs loved them. Would give 5 star but my picky pup refused them. He is SUPER picky though.

Everything came as expected, however the bag isn't filled all the way to the top. Doesn't come as full as it looks in the picture. However, the treats are a decent size. Really squishy and good for hiding pills and medications for puppies and dogs

My dogs love these and I use them for my new puppy to help train. With such an Awesome price these are agreat value.

My puppy really likes these. Price is a good value. Small pieces good for training. Will reorder again.

My dog absolutely loves these, only drawback is they make him super gassy. It's mostly allergen free so that was a bummer for us. We still use them since he loves them so much though.

Great training treats!! Super inexpensive and my dog loves them! My only complaint is that they are sticky and make my hands messy during a training session. For the cost, I can totally put up with sticky smelly hands.

Our yorkie loves them

I have a new golden retriever puppy that I'm training and of all of the training treats I've tried, he LOVES these! I've bought them in all of the flavors and he loves them all.

My dogs liked them but didn't love them. I don't understand my four legged friends I thought they were great.

So happy to find a training treat (or any flavored treat) without fish or seafood in it. My allergies are horrible and these work for both me and my dog. These smell good and my puppy enjoys them. They have made training easier for me and more enjoyable for him. They are a great size, i feed whole or halved (an idea a trainer gave a friend who passed on to me to help with if you need to use them frequently not to upset dogs stomach or over load on calories).

My doggy likes these but they were not great for training purposes. She just didn't like them that much that she would listen during training to get that many of that type.

We are training our chi puppy, so I break each little bite into about 10 smaller pieces for simple command training. She LOVES the taste. I'm cautious about feeding vegetable glycerine in any real quantity because it can cause digestive upset. So far, so good (about 2 treats per day broken into 20 little bits).

I get these in all flavors. My pups love them. My Goldendoodle especially loves the salmon. They are awesome and super moist. So much so that I put them in a treat pouch that's easy access (so it's not completely sealed) 3 day's later and they are still soft. Not like others that leaving to air makes them rock hard.

I bought a bag of the chicken and the beef treats, soft chews. When they arrived and I opened each bag to test them with my pup, I realized the beef flavor treats were HARD AS A ROCK! I couldn't even break one with my finger it was so hard and my puppy certainly couldn't chew it, that's why I get her SOFT CHEWS! The chicken flavored treats were perfect and chewy! She absolutely loves them.... but i can't send them back because the package is open and honestly, it's just too much hassle and shipping would cost more than the treats themselves! They are sold for a great price so we were excited to get them... I'm hesitant to order anymore in fear of getting another batch my pup can't eat, but that's really my only issue with them (although it's def a big one!) these beef treats are going in the trash.

The smell when I opened the bag was very strong a bad smell and the ingredients are horrible please don't feed these to your dogs

The flavor got five stars but I am a human so of course I did not eat them but my dogs seemed to enjoy them quite well. They are perfect for puppies especially when training.

Great for training. The soft texture is great to pull off in tiny pieces so as not to over feed my puppy. She loves the smell and apparently the taste.

Our dogs love them. They are great when helping dog learn commands.They are soft and chewy.I use them for my pitbull and 3 tand 4 lb yorkies

Very sticky an half size of a penny

Not a favorite for my dog, too smoky smelly in my opinion

My two German Shepherds are in love with these treats! One of them even opened their dog supplies container to get this bag. Bought this due to how cheap it was and the healthy ingredients! Will definitely be purchasing much more. The product is super soft. Dark colored. Ok smell. Use this for training !

Perfect sized training treat. I'm a dog trainer and quickly run through treats and am always on the hunt for new ones to try. These have definitely been a hit with my crew! They are the perfect size for a quick reward, and the chewiness helps to add to the speed they eat it so they aren't hunting for crumbs that tend to fall from crunchy ones. The beef flavor seems the most liked; the chicken ones were very crumbly but it may have been that bag. The fish ones were too smelly for my liking. I'm not super thrilled with the ingredients but it's a treat, not a meal, so I'm not too worried.

I use these to reward my dog while we do training. They're a little larger than some of the training treats I've used in the past, but he loves them and the price is great. Definitely recommend. These would be perfect in size for a large dog as a training reward.

Pups love these! Clearly the smell and flavor is one of their favorites. They are nice little pieces so I can feed out several without overdoing it on their treats.

There a perfect size for a puppy in training. My puppy really likes them. The bag is small good for walking around I found it cheaper here then any store...

The dogs will not eat these treats. Amazon will not refund the money. Most pet stores will take back treats if the dogs will not eat them.

Maybe slightly bigger dogs would enjoy these more, but my dog has to spend quite a bit of time chewing them, which kinda breaks the flow of whatever training we are trying to accomplish, especially as she feels she needs to walk over to her "food area" to finish chewing. She definitely like the taste, but if your dog is medium or smaller (under 30 lbs) they might find these a bit tough.

My dog ate one and has refused to eat anymore of them.

My dog refuses to eat any of it...

They stick together

My pup loves these training treats. She's in process of being a therapy dog so she can assist her mama as a social worker. These really encourage her to sit pretty and be nice!

Perfect size for rewarding the dog for everyday good behavior. My dog loves them, just hearing the bag she sits like a good girl and waits. Love the value.

Good chewy treats, our Shiba Inu loves them! They are kind of small so sometimes we bunch two or three of them into one treat to give to our pup!

My dog turned his nose up at it and walked away. He can be picky on occasion, but I have tried multiple times and he just does not seem to care for it. But he does eat it when i drop it in with his kibble, so it is not horrible.He love several of the treats from Costco, so he is not super picky.Was hoping to find something that he just loves so that we could use it for training.

Ingot these at a discounted price so I figured worth a shot. My picky beagle likes them. They do have a strong odor so be forewarned if you grab the fish ones too. They are kind of moist so good for hand feeding, not so much if you have a furbo. They kind of lump together in the machine.

My dog loves these. They are soft but still firm, and actually really great for stuffing pills into. No need to waste money on expensive pill pockets.

My dog kinda sorta likes these treats. I'm not sure if the flavor is something that he is completely crazy about.